When shopping for a brand new TV—maybe round Black Friday—there’s one dilemma you’ll face proper after taking it out of the field: Do you persist with the built-in sensible TV software program, or plug in a separate streaming participant as an alternative?
Each approaches have their deserves. You may get higher efficiency and broader app assist from an exterior streaming participant, however your sensible TV’s software program may supply options which you can’t get by plugging in a Fireplace TV Stick or Roku.
If you happen to’re undecided whether or not you want a streaming participant to make use of along with your sensible TV, right here’s easy methods to determine:
Attempt your sensible TV software program first
Before you purchase a separate streaming participant, give your sensible TV software program a shot. You in all probability don’t want a further streaming machine in case your TV meets all the next standards:
- It has all of the streaming video and music apps you propose to make use of
- It doesn’t really feel unbearably gradual to function
- You’re blissful sufficient with the distant management and menu system
Good TVs get a foul rap for a wide range of causes. Main TV manufacturers, equivalent to Samsung, LG, and Vizio have a tendency to supply fewer apps in comparison with different platforms equivalent to Roku and Fireplace TV, and their observe file for long-term software program updates is worse. Good TVs can be extra privacy-invasive than some streaming gadgets—notably for those who don’t disable their content material recognition techniques that observe what you watch—and so they may use slower processors that drag down responsiveness and cargo occasions.
However not each sensible TV suffers from these issues. If you happen to purchase a TV with Roku, Fireplace TV, or Android TV software program in-built, you’ll get the identical apps and options as their standalone streaming participant counterparts. And the extra you spend on a sensible TV, the extra seemingly its processor shall be sufficiently zippy.
The place sensible TVs excel
Good TVs even have a number of benefits over standalone streaming gadgets. To wit:
Easier HDR setup: In case your TV helps Dolby Imaginative and prescient or HDR10+, your sensible TV apps will assist these codecs routinely. You don’t want to fret about shopping for a appropriate streaming participant, or determining which HDMI enter affords one of the best video high quality. Utilizing the sensible TV software program additionally frees up your HDMI inputs for sport consoles, Blu-ray gamers, or HDMI-ARC soundbars.
Over-the-air integration: Many Samsung and LG TVs include detailed channel guides for over-the-air antennas, as do TVs operating Roku, Fireplace TV, and Android TV software program. Which means you don’t want to change remotes or arrange a networked tuner simply to look at your native channels. (With Roku and Fireplace TV Version televisions, you may even plug in a USB thumb drive to pause and rewind dwell TV.)

Roku and another sensible TVs present full grid guides for over-the-air channels.
Higher voice controls: Some Android TV and Fireplace TV Version televisions—together with Amazon’s new Omni TVs—have far-field microphones built-in, so you may launch movies, management playback, modify the quantity, or change inputs with out touching the distant. Having the mic constructed proper into your TV is easier than establishing a Fireplace TV Dice or making an attempt to pair an exterior sensible speaker to your streaming participant.
Roku speaker assist: If you happen to’re utilizing a Roku TV with the corporate’s soundbars or wi-fi audio system—or TCL’s Roku-ready wi-fi soundbar—you’ll get hassle-free setup and the power to regulate audio settings via your TV’s distant. Which means you received’t want a separate distant simply to regulate the bass or toggle Roku’s dialog enhance function.

TCL’s wi-fi soundbar for Roku TVs takes the effort out of exterior speaker setup.
When a streaming participant is sensible
As I discussed earlier, the primary cause to change to a separate streaming participant is as a result of your sensible TV’s software program is gradual, outdated, or missing in app assist. However there are additionally a number of different the reason why you may wish to ditch the sensible TV performance out of the field:
Extra {hardware} choices: Since Apple doesn’t make doesn’t make sensible TVs, a separate Apple TV field is the one strategy to get essentially the most highly effective streaming machine in the marketplace right this moment, one whose interface can also be refreshingly ad-free. Likewise, the Nvidia Protect TV has no equal if you would like an Android TV participant with the absolute best efficiency.

The Apple TV’s uncluttered interface isn’t obtainable on any sensible TV.
Further options: Except you acquire your TV on the power of its software program, you may find yourself coveting the options of exterior streaming gamers. Roku, for example, affords a wonderful cellular app with personal headphone listening and a “Save Checklist” for monitoring your reveals, whereas Fireplace TV affords a helpful dwell TV information that aggregates a number of video sources into one menu. If you happen to purchased a Samsung, LG, or Vizio TV as an alternative, these sorts of options could also be value switching for.
Ecosystem unification: If all of your TVs run on totally different software program, you may take into account unifying them via exterior streaming gamers. That manner, you get a constant expertise throughout all your televisions. Some streaming platforms, equivalent to Fireplace TV and Google TV, even supply watchlists that sync throughout all of your gadgets, and might play multi-room audio on a number of TVs directly.

Add an merchandise to your watchlist on a Google TV machine, and it’ll sync to all of your others.
Both manner, you don’t have to rush into the choice, nor do you must toss out your total TV if its software program isn’t as much as snuff. However if you’re prepared to interchange your sensible TV software program, you’ll discover loads of exterior gamers and streaming sticks which might be as much as the duty.
Try Jared’s Wire Cutter Weekly e-newsletter for extra recommendation on life with out cable.